Robert Knutson Cases by type
or industry either as Arbitrator or Counsel – A Selected List (E&OE)
08.07.05
Type |
Description |
Parties |
Arbitrator or Counsel |
Year/s |
International Sale of Goods |
|
International Tin Council disputes involving the legal nature
of international organisations, the possibility of putting international
organisations into receivership and attaching their assets. |
Numerous nationalities |
CSL |
80s |
UK v USA |
Dispute over the viability of ITC tin contracts when ITC
was defunct worth many millions of dollars. |
British and American |
CSL |
80s |
German steel co |
Fraud case concerning the sale of rice mills to the Indonesian
Dept of Agriculture $20 million value. |
German and British |
CSL |
80s |
Mr X |
Fraud case concerning recovering money from international fraudster
who obtained a $6 million advance for the sale of tractors for
a roads project in Kuwait, and then kept the money. It involved
defending a criminal defamation case in Switzerland and extensive
use of private investigators. |
Brazilian and American |
CSL |
80s |
Intra UK |
Fall out over forged accounts, specifically forged inventory. |
Jersey and British |
CSL |
80s |
China v USA Seat in London |
Chair of ICC arbitral tribunal considering breach of contract
claim in relation to coal from China to USA. Sequential interpretation
for Chinese witnesses – Award in favour of Claimant. |
Chinese and American |
ARB |
1997-1999 |
Switzerland v BVI
Seat in London |
Ukrainian grain to Mexico – Award published. |
Swiss and BVI |
ARB |
2000-2001 |
Mongolia v Russia
Seat in London |
$100 million plus (estimate) breach of contract dispute with
large elements of public international law. |
Mongolian and Russian |
ARB |
2001-2002 |
Telecoms |
Hardware dispute |
Sole arbitrator in breach of contract dispute. |
Israeli and Swedish |
ARB |
2000 |
Intellectual Property |
Bogus inventor |
Fraud case recouping money from bogus inventor who claimed to
have developed a system better than video, but in fact was using
existing Bell rights. |
Saudi and British |
CSL |
1985 |
Passing off |
Defending US company from UK passing off claim. |
American and British |
CSL |
1990 |
Construction – Airports |
Colombo International Airport, Sri Lanka |
FIDIC dispute between main contractor and subcontractor. |
British and Japanese |
CSL |
1985 |
Myanmar |
Rangoon International airport dispute between Japanese contractor
and government over the effects of civil unrest - FIDIC. |
Japanese and Burmese |
CSL |
1988 |
Italy |
Advice to German lawyers about the relative allocation of risk
in US Government and FIDIC contracts for a US Government contract
in Italy. |
German and American Govt |
CSL |
2001 |
Construction – Dams See also
power stations |
Malaysia |
Advice and preparation of borrow claim regarding earth dam. |
Japanese and Malaysian |
CSL |
80s |
HEP |
Arbitration advice to contractor – 3 ICC arbitrations
commenced. |
Nepalese v. Japanese/Chinese JV |
CSL |
80s |
Construction - Roads |
Sudan |
EOT and additional costs claims. |
German and Sudanese |
CSL |
80s |
England |
Test track for major automaker – suing designers and contractors
for poor quality test track. |
English |
CSL |
80s |
Malaysia |
East-West Highway – Malaysia – claims preparation
and negotiation, including an early (1989) network analysis. |
Japanese and Malaysian |
CSL |
80s |
Construction - Ports (See also
Contract drafting) |
Malaysia |
Kota Kinabalu Port - claims for disruption including omission
of one of three transit godowns. |
Malaysian and Japanese |
CSL |
80s |
Malaysia |
Penang port delay and disruption claims. |
Malaysian and German |
CSL |
90s |
UK |
Dispute of costs of lock construction. |
British |
CSL |
80s |
Type |
Description |
Parties |
Arbitrator or Counsel |
Year/s |
Construction - Tunnels |
Channel Tunnel |
Channel Tunnel Head of legal research on common principles
of law to England and France and lex mercatoria. |
French and British |
CSL |
90s |
SSDS tunnels Hong Kong |
Acting for party in termination claim involving the Hong Kong
Government |
HK SAR and French/Japanese |
CSL |
90s – 2000 |
Construction – Buildings (See
also Contract drafting) |
|
Refurbishment of hotel – Central London. |
|
ARB |
2001 |
|
Luxury restaurant building on Conduit Street London. |
French and English |
CSL |
2002 |
|
Construction of office block Central London EOT claims. |
|
ARB |
2002 |
|
Construction of high rise office block (“Corporate flagship”)
in Central London – adjudication of $50 million claim re. “Time
at large”. |
|
ARB |
2002 |
|
US Embassy, Bahrain claim for defective abstraction of quantities
by QS firm. |
Lebanese/British/American |
CSL |
1998 |
|
Advice regarding form of contract for construction of Japanese
Embassy in Moscow. |
Japanese |
CSL |
2000 |
Construction - Design liability (See
also Roads) |
|
Petrol station claim ownership of and liability to hand over
electronic copies of design documents - outer London. |
|
ARB |
2004 |
Europe |
Eurostar trains |
|
CSL |
1996 |
France/UK |
Channel Tunnel |
|
CSL |
1992-1995 |
Construction – Power stations |
India |
Sole ICC arbitrator by agreement of the parties over bagasse
plant dispute. |
Indian and French |
ARB |
2001-2004 |
Malta |
Advise and claim drafting over whether or not a strike at a
port could be an unforeseen physical condition or obstruction under
FIDIC 3rd edition. |
Maltese |
CSL |
|
Kuwait |
Doha West power station – advice to arbitrator about whether
or not a global claim might succeed. |
Kuwaiti |
CSL |
|
New York New York, USA |
Chairman of AAA (ICDR) arbitration panel in combined cycle electric
power plant. |
|
ARB |
2004 |
Construction - Rail |
|
Claims preparation and negotiation for the Eurostar trains,
including preparation of a very successful CPM network. |
French/British JV and 3 national railways |
CSL |
|
Construction - Plants (See also
Drafting below) |
|
Urea plant in Iraq – delay advice regarding non achievement
of performance specification. |
|
CSL |
90s |
Iraq |
Cement plant in Iraq - claims advice. |
|
CSL |
90s |
UK |
Drafting contract for the construction of a new vehicle factory
for a Japanese company in the UK. |
Japanese and British |
CSL |
90s |
Construction - M&E (See
also Rail) |
UK |
Dilapidations claim. |
British |
CSL |
1986 |
|
HVAC claims central London. |
British |
CSL |
1998 |
Cayman Islands |
Air conditioning claims. |
American/British |
CSL |
1990 |
Oil and Gas |
|
North Sea SPM insolvent main contractor. |
|
CSL |
Mid 80s |
North Sea |
Shipbuilding dispute. |
|
CSL |
Mid 80s |
|
Oil pipeline construction dispute. |
Russian |
ARB |
2003 |
UNCC claim |
Oil pipeline. |
Turkish |
CSL |
Early 90s |
Type |
Description |
Parties |
Arbitrator or Counsel |
Year/s |
Construction – Contract drafting |
British Columbia |
Main contracts for civil works – North East Coal project,
Canada. |
|
CSL |
1981 |
Malaysia |
First draft of shell and core contract for the Petronas twin
towers, Kuala Lumpur. |
|
CSL |
Mid 90s |
Saudi Arabia |
Drafting all contract documents and related contracts for a
port reconstruction project. |
|
CSL |
1995 |
Mozambique |
Drafting a contract for the proposed reconstruction of the Cahora
Basa power plant and transmission lines in Mozambique. |
|
CSL |
Late 90s |
UK - Wales |
Drafting the contracts for the introduction of the necessary
processes for the production of low sulphur diesel in the Elf refinery
(Management contracts). |
|
CSL |
Late 90s |
UK |
Drafting contracts for construction management of a building
refurbishment in the City of London. |
|
CSL |
Late 90s |
Distribution and Agency |
|
Arbitration against German manufacturer on behalf of impecunious
American distributor. |
German and American |
CSL |
|
|
Sole ICC arbitrator in claim against French shoe manufacturer
by British distributor - Award rendered in 6 months. |
German and British |
ARB |
|
|
American goods - Sole arbitrator - dispute over termination
of distribution/agency agreement. |
French and American |
ARB |
|
Insurance and reinsurance |
|
Major Insurance group collapse – suit against Venezuelan
reinsurer. |
British and Venezuelan |
CSL |
|
|
Suit for fraud against British insurers. |
Nigerian and British |
CSL |
|
Securities |
|
|
|
|
|
Listing of Company on NASDAC. |
American/Canada |
CSL |
1982 |
|
Defending investor (by alleging fraud in return) against claim
by liquidator for margin account. |
American and Canadian |
CSL |
1983 |
Maritime |
Charterparty dispute in Admiralty Court. |
British |
CSL |
1985 |
Miscellaneous |
|
Party appointed arbitrator in Joint Venture dispute. |
Canadian/Turkish |
ARB |
2004 |
|
EC law – several cases dealt with concerned alleged breaches
of European law. |
|
|
|
Customs |
Advice to contractor regarding non respect of bulk import waivers
in Iraq. |
|
CSL |
90s |
Worldwide defence of arbitral and court judgments |
Successfully defended a debtor against $1.5 billion worth
of arbitration awards and judgments in several jurisdictions. |
Korean and 122 banks from around the world |
CSL |
1993 |